New Jersey Ruling A Setback For Marriage Amendment Opponents

The New Jersey Supreme court ruled in favor of equal rights for same sex couples today. While leaving open the exact conditions for the legislature, it is a clear victory for the gay rights movement. Although the legislature may opt for civil unions- which is marriage by another name -the intent is clear. What is also clear is the impact this is likely to have on anti-gay marriage votes in the upcoming election. This is a victory for those who want to use the constitution to outlaw gay marriage altogether. As one who has opposed the amendment on the ballot in Virginia, I can say that it's passage is almost assured. Proponents have said all along that these amendments were needed to prevent judges from overreaching and defying the people's will. This case will provide a shining example for them. It is a short sighted victory, in my mind, in that it assures that same sex marriage will be legal in a few liberal states and constitutionally outlawed in most others. Public opinion has been evolving on this issue, and the legislative process, while slower, would have created more successes over time. Now, these amendments will almost assuredly be passed by the voters, and the legislatures won't be able to override them even if they desire to do so.

UPDATE: As predicted, the AP reports: Conservatives hope for backlash from N.J. gay-marriage ruling . They may get their way.